What If Immodesty Is Primarily About Us?

I’ve written a lot about modesty over the last 25 years and today I disagree with a good deal of what I said early on. I realise now what I said years ago was coloured by my own sins and struggles.

When I was in high school, it was common for the girls to wear outfits that didn’t cover much and when they moved they often showed even more. I learned to watch for girls bending over so I could catch a glimpse of panties or breasts. When I stopped looking at porn, that got even worse. The word on the street was those girls knew what they were showing and were doing it either to attract or tease us, and I bought that lie. As I become more serious about my faith, I started to tell myself how horrible these young ladies were for doing that to me. And, of course, being a budding Pharisee, I had to look to see how much they showed so I could properly scold them in my mind.

What changed all this for me was when I was doing Bible study with Lori before we were in any way romantically inclined. We worked on opposite sides of the table and she would sometimes stand up and lean forward to point to something in a reference book I had in front of me. Her shirt would fall forward and there were her breasts in all their glory. I knew she was not coming on to me and realised she had no clue. I eventually told her and she was embarrassed both for what she had shown me and as she realised I was not the only one who she’d given a show.

A naked doll on a red background, with censored over the hips and chest

The truth is most women don’t realise how much they show. What’s more, they don’t see it when other women do it. Even those who are intentionally teasing probably underestimate how much they are showing. And, of course, they also underestimate how much what they show affects us. 

Based on all of this, I have in the past been all about telling women what they are doing and how it affects us. That’s not wrong, but it’s only a piece of the problem. We also need to be telling each other most women are not intentionally coming on to us or teasing us. We need to grow up and deal with our sins rather than putting our sins on women. If a woman shows something she should not, that’s on her. But what a man chooses to do with that is on him. In Job 31:1Job says, “I have made a covenant (agreement) with my eyes; How then could I gaze [lustfully] at a virgin?” [Amplified]

Lust is not an excuse to look at what women show. Once I understood the issue and matured enough to no longer want to see it, I used the skills I had honed to see things as a way to avoid seeing. I recall one day being at the bank. The teller, who was shorter than I, was wearing a flouncy blouse. As she bent forward to work on my deposit I look away so as not to see what I knew she was about to expose. If we work at it, we can avoid a lot of lust by seeing the unintentional invitations coming and avoiding them.

The other change I’ve made is in how I see women who are “immodest”. I choose to see them as victims of a society that sees women as things rather than wanton women trying to entice me. They are people Jesus loves, not porn on a stick for my enjoyment.

A post worth reading:

Desiring God | The Safest Man for Women: A Guide Toward Sexual Purity ◄ Great thoughts on purity.

Image Credit: © Natasha | stock.adobe.com
Shop Amazon ♦ Shop to give links page
We’re donation supported Thanks for your help!
This post may contain affiliate links, see my disclosure for info.

4 responses to “What If Immodesty Is Primarily About Us?”

  1. Middle Man says:

    Great post.

  2. Tory says:

    Wow, Paul. Amazingly self-aware and humble. Thank you for seeing women as people.

  3. @Tory “Thank you for seeing women as people.”

    It’s an interesting thing. I have several close female friends (no romantic interest) in high school, so I learned a good deal about what women face from men. It was easy to see those young ladies as people. But when I saw a woman I didn’t know wearing too little, I was less likely to see her that way.

    That changed as I learned and matured.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.