I read an interesting study done on picky eaters. The short version is if you make eating a battle, your child will fight you over everything they eat and will likely become a picky eater. What most parents do to “fix” children’s eating problems actually makes thing much worse.

And I got to thinking, do some of us do this with our wife and sex?
I’m not suggesting your wife is a child, but what kids do with eating is pretty basic human nature. They want to be in control, and they really, really don’t want you to be in control. If they stretch out a meal to more than an hour they prove they have some control even if they eventually eat the food.
If sex is a battle for you and your wife, it’s become a control issue. If she “gives in” occasionally she is still proving she has some control. If she refuses certain acts for no apparently sane reason, she is showing she has control. Even not having an orgasm could sometimes be about control.
If you think you’re living this I don’t have any surefire fixes. But like parents fighting kids who won’t eat, I suspect most of what you do is making the problem worse.
If what you’ve been doing isn’t working, I suggest you try something else. And keep trying.
Image Credit: © Scott Griessel | stock.adobe.com
Shop Amazon ♦ Shop to give links page
We’re donation supported Thanks for your help!
This post may contain affiliate links, see my disclosure for info.
Control, control, control…..that is the antithesis of married sexuality. If either are trying to control the sex in their marriage, either for or against, it isn’t going to bode well.
If any psychologist wants to make good money, there’s a niche market in emptying baggage that leads to sexual control and refusal.
I’ve never been a refuser, so I am not an expert, but since you’re using a food analogy, let’s try it. I know what it feels like to eat food I hate, and it is similar to having sex when I really don’t want to. I hate liver, but I could eat it with a reasonably pleasant expression if I force myself to and could fake enthusiasm if I felt it was expected, but I would feel weirdly false. If someone were to demand that I eat liver regularly, I would definitely look for ways to avoid it and eat it less frequently. I guess it could be called ‘control’ since obviously I do prefer to have control over what goes into my mouth or any other body part. “If she refuses certain acts for no apparently sane reason…” This line actually angers me. Because I’ve read your other stuff and most of it is awesome and I agree with it, I imagine we’re not actually that far apart on this either. I’m certainly no raging feminist, and I’m extremely pro-sex in marriage but if she refuses certain sex acts and you don’t understand her reason, suck it up. She has a reason, you can try to figure it out, but if you can’t get over it, you’re the pouty child in this scenario.
What I think this analogy shows best, is that if she’s limiting sex because she hates it, the goal is to help her to like it, not to demand that she do it frequently with great enthusiasm and variety for the rest of her life even though she hates it the whole time. Obviously this is on her too…big time! But if she can be given hope that the meal isn’t liver, it’s something you both like, at least she has somewhere to start. Little bites, with freedom…and yes, control over her own body and what goes into it.
@Dandelion – If she has a reason and won’t share it, isn’t that about her? Refusing to communicate is rude and often manipulative. It’s “If you don’t know, I’m not going to tell you”.
PIcky eaters don’t hate food. It’s not about the food, it’s about control. That might not translate perfectly to sex, but I think it’s often the case.
@Paul, you said – “It’s “If you don’t know, I’m not going to tell you”.”
Dandelion didn’t say that the woman wouldn’t share the reason. She said, “if she refuses certain sex acts and you don’t understand her reason…”.
Seems to me that Dandelion is talking about wives who have indeed stated their reason, and the husband does not understand the given reason.
@Wife -You may well bve right. Could be a gender issue.
However, she went on to say “She has a reason, you can try to figure it out” which is why it sounds like “If you don’t know, I’m not going to tell you” to me. And to every other man I suspect.
Paul, I’m not sure that the study you linked is actually saying what you state.
You said: “The short version is if you make eating a battle, your child will fight you over everything they eat and will become a picky eater.”
In the study, parents were asked to respond to questionnaires describing their child’s level of picky eating and how the parents were handling the issue. This was done when the child was age 4, 5, 8 and 9.
The article states: “Lower levels of picky eating in children were associated with parents imposing few restrictions on foods and a lack of pressure to eat.”
Does this association imply causation? The article does not claim there is a causal relationship (ie. the lack of pressure and restrictions CAUSED lower levels of picky eating).
Interestingly, there was nothing saying, “Higher levels of picky eating were associated with….”, so we are left uninformed regarding the pickier eaters.
From what the article states about the study, there is no way to determine whether the lack of pressure/restrictions LED TO the lower levels of picky eating, or whether it was the other way around. Both are in the realm of possibility, but (at least from the article you linked) the study is not claiming to have found a causal relationship one way or the other. It was merely stating a correlation.
I think it’s a bit of a leap to state: “if you make eating a battle, your child will fight you over everything they eat and will become a picky eater.”
I cannot see how the study supports your conclusion here.
My own thoughts – I’m not sure the eating issue is about control. It seems more likely that children (and people in general) just want to eat things that taste nice (or at least things that don’t taste bad). The child who drags the mealtime out to an hour or more is probably just trying to avoid eating something that they really dislike. Does that mean they want control? No, they just don’t want to have to taste any more of that liver.
I don’t know how this applies to the sexual relationship between husband and wife, and I’m not making any claims of such. I just do not believe that the study you cited supports the claim you made.
@Wife – Does it IMPLY causation? Yes, rather strongly. Prove it? No. Add what we know about human behaviour, and I think it’s pretty obvious.
As for control, I’ve talked to experts who say kids can control two things, what goes into their body and what comes out. And kids who are feeling out of control will manipulate both of those.
Sadly much of what happens between people comes down to control.
You are free to make your own claims of what causes what, and say that XYZ is obvious.
The study was not making those claims, so I don’t see how it is fair for you to state that it did.
By all means, cite the study, but if you are adding in your own causal implications and your knowledge of human behaviour, then please make this clear to us readers.
@Wife – If you don’t agree with the study, fine. But please don’t accuse me of making things up when what I said is clearly stated in the article I linked to:
“Demanding that a child eat, or restricting food are associated with some of the pickiest eaters, according to the study, published Tuesday in the journal Pediatrics.
“Eating is one of the few domains kids can exert some control over,” said senior author Dr. Megan Pesch, a developmental and behavioral pediatrician at Michigan Medicine C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital.”
Association is not causation.
Your statement was a causal one. Theirs was not.
The study design does not allow scope for identifying cause and effect. It only shows correlation.
If you don’t accept that, then that’s fine. We will have to agree to disagree.
@Wife – I’ve already said there was no causation proven. However, looking back at my post I stated the connection too strongly. Changing that.
But I’m standing by what I said about control. Both this study and others support the idea, as does child psychology in general. Kids want and need to feel a certain level of self-determination. When the don’t feel they have that, bad things happen.
@Paul: “PIcky eaters don’t hate food. It’s not about the food, it’s about control.”
I disagree. Picky eaters don’t hate food – they hate eating food that tastes BAD.
If it tastes bad, they’re probably going to find ways to avoid eating it. This is what Dandelion was getting at.
Children know that there is good tasting food out there – they’ve had plenty of it in their lifetime. When they come across something that tastes bad, they naturally are not keen on eating it, and would prefer to eat something that actually tastes nice (wouldn’t we all?).
You say it’s about control. If you dish up nice tasting food consistently, where’s the battle? I would say there would be a very small minority of children who would choose to battle over food when it tastes nice (unless you are trying to overfeed them), and the reasons they are battling over the nice tasting food is NOT because the parents are too restrictive about food.
There are so many variables that are involved in the behaviour of children at mealtimes that it is not easy to just point the finger at a child not wanting to eat a meal, and declare that it is because the parents are too restrictive with food.
I get what you are trying to say with all this, but I don’t think your picky eating argument holds up.
I have had many years of dealing with mealtimes with many children. I don’t think I’ve ever seen ‘control’ enter the equation when a child is being difficult with food.
Taste? Yes.
Control? No.
I don’t see the picky eating arguments as translating to sex.
When my kids were younger I used to read dozens of blogs about childhood nutrition and picky eaters. I think the subject is much more nuanced than anyone proposing a quickfire solution which is what a lot of the mommy blogs would do. Approach of the parents definitely matters.
You state in an earlier comment that picky eaters don’t hate food, that they just want to be in control–how could we possibly know that?
I was a picky eater as a child…my parents did some things experts said they should do and other things they said they should not. There are things that I still won’t eat as an adult that I wouldn’t eat as a child. Many of them are fish, like pickled herring, tuna or salmon. Other things that I think I should be able to eat, like deviled eggs, I just can’t. My sister liked all of those foods.
No doubt I wanted to have control over the expectation I should eat foods I considered repulsive.
It has been researched that some people perceive the taste of cilantro differently based on genetic factors–don’t know why this couldn’t hold true for other foods. The smell of some foods probably makes them harder to tolerate for some picky eaters—I can’t even be in the same room as liver when it cooks.
@Denise – If parents make kids picky eaters, then I think it applies to sex. If no, it does not.
One we know it’s about control is many picky eaters stop liking food the once liked. Yes tastes change, but usually, we like more food, not less.
I do have some first-hand experience with this. My grandson has a friend who comes with him to visit us. The friend is a picky eater. An hour or more at the table after the family is done and won’t touch any new food. But one day when they were here my grandson asked for dried mango. The friend had never had them and said no. Then my grandson told him how good they were and offered him one. He ate it, and he liked it. In fact, he’s tried everything we’ve offered him. There is no control issue here, so he’s free to try things.
My son was the least picky eater I’ve ever known. The only two things he ever complains about were meatloaf and gravy (who doesn’t like gravy?). So we never asked him to eat those two things. When a guest made meatloaf for us we made my son something else. The guest was offended.