Joe cheats on his wife with woman after woman. When Joe’s wife files for divorce we call her a horrible person and questionS her salvation.
Sue refuses Ted sex for years. So Ted divorces Sue and he’s the bad person.
Sam beats Chris. Chris is the victim until she says “the D word” and suddenly he’s the victim and she needs to repent.
I’ve seen these things. They happen.

And for every marriage like those, there are at least half a dozen other marriages where neglect, addictive behaviour, rage, and other sins run rampant.
What if we were as upset about the sins that can result in divorce as we are about divorce? What if instead of sweeping those things under the carpet, we called the guilty spouse on the carpet? What if being a bad spouse meant you were disqualified from any paid or volunteer job in the church? What if unloving spouses were pushed to get help? What if the things that lead to divorces got as much attention as divorce?
If we believe God hates divorce, how must He feel about the actions that lead to divorce?
Image Credit: © Mincemeat | stock.adobe.com
Shop Amazon ♦ Shop to give links page
We’re donation supported Thanks for your help!
This post may contain affiliate links, see my disclosure for info.
Here’s the thing, the person who initiates the legal paperwork for the divorce is still the divorcee in these cases, because the offending spouse divorced them and broken their marriage vows long before the lawyer was called.
We often point to the statistic of women being the divorce initiators in the majority of cases, but what they don’t cover is WHY. I’m going to run through the divorced women I know personally:
1. Her husband “checked out.” He was just an entity in their home, and resented marrying young. But, he liked having a cook and house cleaner and ready sex partner, so he never filed for divorce.
2. Her husband verbally abused her, refused her medical care, broke her things, and kicked her dogs, but didn’t want the stigma of divorce.
3.After 20 years of verbal, emotional, and so,etimes sexual and physical abuse, she faced her “God hates divorce” fears when she saw he was beginning to act that way towards their child because she was now working when he was home and he didn’t have her to victimize. He also knew she belonged to the “God hates divorce” crowd and used it as a control tool against her an refused to be the divorce initiator.
4. He left her and cheated on her, starting a new life in another city, and admitting her tricked her into marrying him. He tricked an entire church! He faked his salvation and became music minister and deacon, only to admit it was all a lie, and left.
5. His interest in motorcycles turned into gang and drug involvement. Cheating, abuse, and complete financial ruin, and the ultimatum of join this dangerous biker gang lifestyle and leave God or leave.
6. Porn addiction, borderline personality disorder, controlling abuse with a jumbled mix of hand-picked Bible verses and selfish worldly choices until his happy bride was a drooped shell. The church had to help her leave and enacted church discipline.
In all these cases, the men didn’t initiate legal divorce. The woman did. But, I maintain that in most divorces, the husband or the wife long divorces through their actions and breaking of vows before the hurting spouse realizes the marriage is no more or needs safety, and initiates legal divorce.
@libl – I suspect more often than not the one who files is more of a victim than the other spouse. And because women tend to be more relational, they are less likely to be willing or even able to continue in a deeply broken marriage.
” And because women tend to be more relational, they are less likely to be willing or even able to continue in a deeply broken marriage.”
Let’s not ignore the elephant in the room – divorce courts are heavily biased in favor of women, so men are far less likely to want to pull the trigger.
@Tom – That’s the common mantra, but it’s not nearly as true as many claim.
Statistically divorced women are worse off financially than divorce men, and fear of financial problems keeps some women in horrible marriages.
For the most part, the court cares about the children, and does what it can to ensure there is enough money to raise them well.
https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/04/the-divorce-gap/480333/
Lots of the women I know were left penniless and starting from scratch with kids, while the ex-husband, other than child support, got on with life, and his new woman.
The men I see fare worse with child support are the unwed fathers who break up with baby-mommy.
Dr Willard Harley says he cannot get women who are victims to initiate divorce. He finds that most who initiate divorce have clueless, but not abusive nor adulterous husbands.
https://www.marriagebuilders.com/why-women-leave-men.htm
“Surprisingly few women divorce because of physical abuse, infidelity, alcoholism, criminal behavior, fraud, or other serious grounds. In fact, I find myself bewildered by women in serious physical danger refusing to leave men that threaten their safety.”
The women cite cruelty and neglect, which is certainly solvable.
It simply takes getting on the same page, and taking seriously the need of both the husband and the wife.
I suspect just as many men could cite cruelty and neglect, but choose not to.
@Tony – I would note he said “physical abuse”. Divorce for emotional abuse is far more common. For that matter, the line between neglect and emotional abuse can be difficult to find.
I hear “adultery” as a cause for divorce rather regularly. However, more often than not it’s not the real reason, just the justification. Claims of abuse, as opposed to actual abuse, are the same way, sadly.
Anyone can claim abuse.
Heck, my ex-wife tried to suggest I was controlling. Of course, not wanting to give her money so she could go get an apartment and have her affair out of my sight is her definition of controlling.
It’s also the standard wording for no-fault divorce. It’s used so often to be meaningless.
If we are counting on court documents and or the accounts of people who betray their spouses to be honest about this, I think we may be trying to rely on data of dubious quality.
Some people call your boundaries controlling. If I limit how much money I want to spend, to me that’s a boundary. That’s something I decide about myself. If someone else doesn’t like my decisions, they often call it controlling, or selfish, or whatever.
My ex-wife made budget after budget, that she agreed to, and then exceeded. We went back and adjusted it numerous times and every time she found a reason she couldn’t adhere to it.
I paid off about $75k in debt WHILE the divorce was in progress while she was out of the house and no longer had access to the funds.
But IIIII was the one who was controlling and bad with money, if you were to listen to her.
Fiscally, divorce might have been the best thing to happen to me. It limited how much of my earnings she could impact, by court order.
So if she thought I was controlling, imagine her disappointment when the judge said I did not have to pay for her lawyer, she wouldn’t be getting alimony, that since I’d been voluntarily paying the state mandated child support during the process before a court order was in place, there was no back support for her.
She did however manage to get a lien placed on our home (that I kept during the divorce) as she didn’t pay her first attorney.
Sorry, when someone who is breaking their vows cries abuse or controlling, I take it with a grain of salt.
Not saying it cannot happen. I’m just saying their claims should be examined closely.
Of course, she hit me, and when I reported that to the police, nothing was done.
Sorry, I have a hard time just taking such claims at face value given what I’ve experienced.
I think we should make sure accusers are safe. But if they are not honorable in other parts of their life, such as having affairs, not not honoring their words such as making mutual agreements about budgets and then essentially ignoring them, then should we really take their complaint at face value without some examination?
That’s my complaint about no-fault divorce. It’s easy to make such a claim, but there is no independent verification
Proverbs 18:17 The first to plead his case seems right, Until another comes and examines him.
So akin to Ronald Reagan, protect, but verify such claims.
Sorry so long, it’s a touchy issue.
Finally, since we are on emotional abuse, an affair is pretty abusive, as I’ve shared with you before. Dr Harley has spoken with people who have suffered rape, the loss of a loved one and being betrayed by a spouse. Most will tell you that being betrayed by a spouse is the most hurtful thing they’ve experienced.
https://www.marriagebuilders.com/how-to-survive-infidelity.htm
“Those I’ve counseled who have had the tragic misfortune of having experienced rape, physical abuse, sexual abuse of their children, and infidelity have consistently reported to me that their spouse’s unfaithfulness was their very worst experience. To be convinced of the devastating impact of infidelity, you only need to go through it once.”
So let’s not discount the abusive nature of affairs as many are want to do.
Great post sir. Thank you
Having gone through this pretty recently I have a different perspective, especially after a number of people have opened up to me about their divorce, and other guys started opening up to me about their marriage troubles. Yes, people do awful things to one another…..but those highly conflicted cases are only a small part of it. None of that was the cause of mine, there was no affair that I can prove…..although I kinda suspect, there was no abuse, there was no money problems, there was no drug use; it was two people who worked a lot and had different priorities that spun out of control. She made it a priority to volunteer at the church, and to volunteer at the kids sports stuff, and to make it to every sunday school mom’s night out. When I started pushing back because I needed attention and was unhappy about our sex life….or lack thereof, she told me I expected too much. She continued prioritizing everything but me, I turned to porn for sex and I turned to my friends for emotional connection, and my hobbies to occupy my time. I was no longer willing to accommodate what she wanted because what I wanted wasn’t important to her. I saw on here something about once a week being the gold standard, that’s nonsense, I had sex once a week and I said that was completely unacceptable, especially if she was telling me she was too tired and kept doing all of her volunteering. I gave her no grace, nor any way to back up. She emotionally checked out and said she wanted a divorce, but wouldn’t do anything about it, so I filed and got it over with. She is still in a volunteer leadership position with the church, when I don’t think that she should be. If she went to them and complained about my porn use and I was in that situation, I would have been removed…..however, she quit her marriage and now has her boyfriend staying over when the kids are there, and not a word is said to her even when I brought it up to the senior pastor. I’m not saying I’m an angel, but I do not pretend to be, nor do I volunteer in an official capacity at any church.
@mykidsmademedoit – You didn’t see me say once a week was the gold standard. I’d put it more at four times a week.
Unravelling the causes of divorce can be difficult. You have a series of thing done as a reaction to what the other does or does not do. Blaming it on the last thing, or the big thing, is far from accurate and not at all honest.
Yes, very seldomly does one incident do it. It is more a series of things that got you there, but the focus is on the one thing. Even with an affair…..unless it was like a drunken night of stupidity, most of the time it took a while for that person to get to the point they were willing to step out. We however put all of the focus on the partner that did the one thing.
” I’d put it more at four times a week.”
Whee! If I told my wife that, she’d run away screaming. I’m lucky if it happens four times every six weeks.
@mykidsmademedoit – ” I saw on here something about once a week being the gold standard, that’s nonsense”
I said that. And the context was that it felt to me like many wives consider once a week to be the gold standard. In other words, if they have sex once a week, the husband shouldn’t have anything to complain about. I actually agree with Paul that four times a week is closer to what SHOULD be the gold standard. In other words, more days than not.
Ah, ok. I agree with that point then. My ex wife thought that once maybe twice a week of being a starfish should be enough. Four times a week is a much more accurate point to keep men out of trouble. I honestly don’t know what a reasonable expectation is, I agree most women in long term relationships probably agree with the once a week thing, and most men deal with that by then going to porn for the other three or four times they need……so then 3/4 of your sexual energy is directed as something other than your spouse……that’s a big problem.
A christian-based health book called Trim, Healthy Mama has a chapter on sex. They say, “at least twice a week, make the bed squeak!”
A healthy married woman, even a busy mom of many children, should be sexually active at least twice a week. More, if logistically possible.
We find 3x per week to work for us.
I’m not speaking directly to anyone else’s situation, but here is where I struggle with 4 times a week being a gold standard. That is a gold standard for what a man’s body wants for release. I believe those needs are valid and need to be acknowledged in the marriage.
Equally, I think it needs to be acknowledged the gold standard for the woman/low drive/responsive sex drive partner. Most women I talk to would say that their husbands’ don’t put in the time, romance and emotional connection to prepare their wives for a good sexual encounter 4 times a week, where they can respond and have fun (not just lay there).
I’ll just speak personally. The first half of my marriage we were so disconnected, for so many reasons that were fault on both sides, that I didn’t feel emotionally capable of engaging in sex in any way positive. We hit a point about 6 years in where I decided to never say no…and all that did was lead to disconnected sex that made me feel used.
Men cannot turn off their sex drive and sexual needs-valid concern and point for the marriage
Most women cannot engage in sex with a man that is not spiritually and emotionally connecting with her-valid concern and point for the marriage.
I honestly don’t know what the answer is, other than both parties have to strive to be unselfish and must fight hard for sexual, emotional and spiritual connection.
My $0.02, and it’s generic as well as I don’t know you or your situation. I think both have to make it pleasurable to connect be it emotionally or physically.
I think many times women, (just as men do) sabotage their efforts to connect.
Just last week, I asked my wife how I could help with the house cleaning efforts for yesterday’s Super Bowl party.
The response wasn’t an “It would be great if you took on these tasks…” instead it was more of “You are an adult, you should know what to do…” sort of response. Take initiative, and so on.
Here is the problem from my perspective, she has a particular way of doing things and sometimes wants to do them herself. Heck, apparently, there is even a right and wrong way for me to say I realize there is a lot to do and I’d like to help, as I got my head bitten off for bringing it up as I did.
So in this case, she claims she’s overwhelmed, but then takes shots at her partner.
Do you think I’m going to be keen on volunteering again, given that response?
Generically, I see it all the time, women say they want men to express emotions, and when they do, they are told they are the wrong emotions, or that their emotions are not deep, or what they express is carnal.
Okay, who is going to sign up for even more of that? They tried it, they were critiqued and give the tacit message that she doesn’t want him to share ALL his emotions, only the “right” emotions, and presumably only in “approved” by her ways.
So he plays it safe, given his prior experience, and shares nothing at all, because it is emotionally unsafe for him to do it otherwise.
So my #1 tip for those who want their man to share and connect more emotionally is to actually mean what you say, and allow him to do so. Recognize that he’s going to both have different emotions and express them in different ways.
You will get more of what you reward (the expression of his emotions) and you will get less to none if you criticize his expressions.
Note, I’m not saying put up with abuse, or anything of that sort. What I’m saying is if you want his emotional expressions, you cannot be so critical that you call his expressions childish, or shallow, or base, or carnal or however you might be tempted to characterize them.
You married him for who he is right? So why are you now trying to change him, or suddenly unwilling to accept who he is? He’s not a home-improvement project where you mold him into what you want him to be. That’s the job of the Holy Spirit, not you.
If he’s not emotionally open to you, is it possible that you’ve sent the message by your words or deeds that it’s not a good idea for him to open up as you’ll cut him down?
I’ve had similar experiences where being more communicative leads to negative comments and criticism. I’ve also had similar experiences with trying to be helpful but getting critiqued rather negatively because I didn’t do it right, or her version of right. It DOES make it really hard to continue to be communicative. I find myself constantly weighing the pros and cons of opening my mouth and saying something. Enough negative experiences and it becomes really hard to have a conversation. What makes it frustrating is conversation, interaction, and being emotionally present are the things she needs most from me. I want to give her that, but many times I’m afraid if I try, it’ll come back to bite me. So I get where you’re coming from, Tony.
@closertotheheart – Yeah, sometimes when a man won’t talk or won’t help it’s because his wife has pushed him to that place.
I really do understand this, as I had that kind of experience as well. My husband was angry, critical and spoke harshly to me. We actually had mutual friends who spent much time in our house sit down with him and call him to account on this, that he was mean to me. It got to the point that I was cautious to share anything, as it was met with criticism and a parenting type response. This was the climate of the home he grew up in, very critical, very shaming.
I felt very unsafe, which of course made it impossible to engage in sex in a good way, which is why sex got to be its own kind of trauma. My husband was angry because we weren’t having sex, so I didn’t say no, but I had to check out of the trauma that it was to engage in such an intimate act with a man that was a stranger to me, and mean to me.
This is very complicated, which is why I have an issue with their being a gold standard of how many times a week sex should be happening. How can we say sex should happen 4 times a week, when no emotional connection is happening? How can we say sex should happen 4 times a week if their is no spiritual connection happening?
@Wheat48 – I get what you’re saying too. I think what I meant when I suggested this was it’s a good number to strive for (and succeed more often than not) when both parties are putting their best efforts into the relationship. I think in a case like yours, a heart-to-heart needs to be had. Something like, “I want to be there for you sexually as much as you need, but it’s hard when I struggle with feeling emotionally connected with you. And that stems from feeling unsafe in being open with you because I fear that you will be critical with me if I do open up to you. Can we work on having a safer environment for communicating openly with each other? Is there something I can be doing differently in my communication style that might help you be less critical?”
Thankfully, Praise God!, I’m speaking about our past. We went to counseling, and that was a huge turnaround in our marriage. My husband changed and it created a safe environment where I could then began to address my issues with sex. This piece with my husband was big, but I also have a history of sexual assault and abuse.
Paul- I think that might be the other piece in a lot of situations where the husband gives 110%, but the wife still doesn’t move towards more sex. Sadly, many women have this history of sexual abuse and assault.
@Wheat48 – I agree with you on abuse and assault. That, and being taught sex is dirty as a child.
@Wheat48 – As I wrote somewhere, probably on The XY Code, part of the discussion is explaining the relational foundation necessary to have sex that often.
@Wheat48 – I often talk to guys about what a woman needs to find sex easy.
That said:
If a woman gives her husband 110% of what he wants, the odds are high he will start giving her far more of what she needs.
If a man gives his wife 110% of what he wants, she may start having more sex, but the odds are not nearly as good as for what I said above. I don’t know what that is, but I know it is. Several guys here will tell you they have gone above and beyond AND THEIR WIFE AGREES and there is still no more sex.
I think that part of the problem is that divorce is easy to see – in fact, almost impossible not to – but all those other things are easy to hide. If they are seen, they are easy to explain away, justify or write off as less important. Plus, no one wants to call them out because, I imagine every marriage suffers one or more of these, to some degree, and no one wants to be called out to deal with the plank in their own eye – particularly church leaders and their spouses.
@JH – True. Of course, we are told to remove the plank SO WE CAN help with the splinter. The reality is we are our brother’s keeper!
I agree, but how do we even know it’s happening until it’s too late? Even if we are able to get church leadership on board to block refusers from serving in the church, most people are so private about their sex lives (which is otherwise a good thing) that no one knows until the wronged spouse has filed – or at least checked out.
@JH – It would certainly take some changes in how we deal with and feel about marriage.
Paul,
I really liked this post. I think it is good to talk about divorce it is happening and pretending it isn’t doesn’t help anyone. From people who I have known who have gone through divorce to my own relationship it seems like it’s not always this big issue causes the divorce but rather the refusal of the spouse to work on it. I knew of one couple where the wife just refused to have sex with her husband. He wasn’t an awful guy, she just never liked it and was done with it. He tried to deal with it and then do counseling. She refused to budge so they divorced. The sad part is had there been sexual assault in her past, didn’t enjoy sex etc etc he would have been willing to work with her. She wouldn’t do it. Would not talk about it just said over and over I don’t want to anymore. It seems like a lot of people find themselves in this type of situation. One spouse digs their heels in over sex and won’t work on it. Could be porn or refusal or a whole other number of issues. What should the spouse do then? In the case of the couple that I knew the church tried to intervene and work with them. She wouldn’t budge. He filed, he is looked at as the man who left his wife. Yes, she refused and he was probably within his rights to file for divorce based on abandonment. But the bigger issue seemed to be her refusal to even discuss it. I wanted to shake some sense into her.
Getting divorced didn’t get her out of having sex, it just got her out of having sex with him. The reality is she will start having sex with someone new, and then get tired of that, and the cycle will start again. Men she dates will be far less accommodating of no sex than her husband was.
You are probably right. This is what I don’t understand. He wasn’t perfect and I don’t know everything but by her own admission he was a good father, a good provider, didn’t drink etc and didn’t use porn. Wasn’t awful to her or abusive. Just wanted to have sex with his wife. When she spoke about it she really had the attitude of I just don’t want to. She sounded like a child being forced to eat her vegetables. It was maddening.
You did the right thing in calling her out on it though. The church needs to get better at that – making it clear in cases like this that although the one filing for divorce is doing something more visible, the refuser is the one sinning. Most people somehow seem to miss that the exception for marital infidelity includes refusal.
I should have said this before: Way to go, Paul! Another spot-on, challenging post!
I would just be happy if we stopped blaming victims in the church.
Wife has an affair and the husband is asked what he did to force her to have an affair.
No questions about what he did to actually work on his marriage. No acknowledgement that he quit is travel heavy job several years ago at the request of his wife, but he saw no movement on her part. No answers to his questions about what she wanted, what it looked like, or could she give examples of when he got it right so he could duplicate those efforts. No answer to his respectful request to have just an hour a day where it was just the two of them. No TV, no kids, etc.
Sure, he’s the bad guy because she was unhappy, while saying everything was fine.
As others have said, not suggesting he was perfect, just pointing out that more often than not, the victim of her affair and choice to divorce is / was also miserable, but didn’t have a partner open to the work and honest about how she feels.
@Tony – No argument on that. And of course, it happens with the genders reversed too. I’ ve heard a lot of women blamed for their husband having an affair and even for beating them!