Adultery Doesn’t Improve Marriages

I’ve heard people suggest a way to save a marriage headed for divorce is to have an affair.

Yes, really!

Couple on bed, with a phone call from "Wife".

Some will even point to things said by therapists to support that. Of course, these things are almost always taken out of context. As an example:

“Ms. Perel and other marriage counselors have found, couples that choose to recover from and rebuild after infidelity often end up with a stronger, more loving and mutually understanding relationship than they had previously.“

See the part in bold? That’s the key. To make it even clearer, try this:

“People who’ve been betrayed need to know that there’s no shame in staying in the marriage — they’re not doormats, they’re warriors. The gift they provide to their families by working through the pain is enormous.”

Again, note the part in bold.

Yes, some couples who deal with adultery come out the other end with a better marriage. The reason for this is not the adultery, but the choices and hard work that came after the infidelity.

Adultery is often a sink or swim moment for a marriage. No marriage remains the same. Some thrive, some die, and some remain crippled the rest of the couple’s lives.

I’ve talked to many individuals and couples who survived adultery. Some do say it motivated them to change in a way that was great for their marriage, but none has ever told me they are glad it happened.

Quotes from When a Partner Cheats | The New York Times

Related Resource: Healing from Infidelity: The Divorce Busting® Guide to Rebuilding Your Marriage After an Affair by Michele Weiner-Davis

Image Credit: © Nomad_Soul | stock.adobe.com
Shop Amazon ♦ Shop to give links page
We’re donation supported Thanks for your help!
This post may contain affiliate links, see my disclosure for info.

10 responses to “Adultery Doesn’t Improve Marriages”

  1. Tony says:

    So how do you get your wife to end her affair and buy into this?

    Having gone through this, I’m convinced I would not try to save a marriage impacted by adultery. If my wife could not be honest with me and tell me what she wanted or needed or was missing when she chose to get it via an affair, I don’t know if I could go on.

    I’ve tried to fix a marriage where my wife cheated, and I asked, what was I not doing to lead you to do this, only to get no answer.

    So while some may claim it can be better, my experience is the cheating spouse is unwilling or unable to be honest about what she’s done and steadfastly holds on to the fantasy of the affair, with a single regard to the hurt and pain she’s inflicted upon her family.

    If your cheating wife is like this, she is not a good partner and one would be well advised to protect themselves and their children from such a selfish, hurtful, abusive person.

    Affairs are a form of abuse. It is emotionally abusive to be dishonest with your spouse. Until the cheater can become a safe spouse, your best bet is to NOT seek to reconcile.

    • @Tony – You are exactly right. Many don’t survive. Moving past it require hard work from both spouses.

      I also think some folks have an affair as a way of ending their marriage. There is no recovery from that!

  2. Janna says:

    There was great caution when said this, because it could be easily misconstrued, and we are talking an EA (mine), but my husband has said to me, “In a way, I am glad it happened.” Why, because that is what it took to truly wake him up. And because of those bolded parts, there were veils removed that had never been removed in 24 years of marriage, so in essence, we did get closer because of it.

    Would it have been nice if we could have learned the easy way? Sure. But we are a stubborn lot, and too often it takes a hot fire to bring up that dross (sin) within us, so that we can get rid of it.

  3. “Yes, some couples who deal with adultery come out the other end with a better marriage. The reason for this is not the adultery, but the choices and hard work that came after the infidelity.”

    Paul, these words you wrote above is precisely how we came out the other end still together. No, I absolutely NEVER wanted adultery to happen in our marriage – but it did. We chose together as a couple to do the work – to walk the long, difficult road to healing and reconciliation. It was THE most painful thing I have ever been through in this life, and I don’t think I could survive it again. (Once was way more than enough!)

    Today, we truly are better in our marriage than we ever were before the dark days of infidelity. But it took work… grace, forgiveness, reflection, and a cruise ship full of PAIN. Never in a million years would I ever counsel anyone to go have an affair to improve their marriage. That would be akin to prescribing heroin or rat poison for a headache. I question the sanity of anyone calling themselves “mentor” or “counselor”, if this is what they’re telling people.

    ~Jason

  4. J. Parker says:

    Yes, sometimes we can confuse God taking a terrible situation and bringing good from it for that situation itself being good. And they are not the same.

    Every now and then, I’ve had someone suggest it was good that I had a premarital promiscuous past because that set me on the road to marriage ministry. I find that preposterous! No, my sin was never good, and if I could go back and make different decisions, I would! And if God wanted me in marriage ministry, He’d find another way to get me there.

    The real issue you address here is when and how are we willing to listen to God’s calling to nurture our marriage! It should not take the horrible jolt of an affair. Thanks for covering this, Paul.

  5. Jay says:

    Great post, Paul!
    Just wanted to mention that there are different reasons why people get into affairs. It sounds to me like you are talking about situations where there is lack of attention or even neglect in the marriage. But if the reason is severe damage or trauma due to abuse, like sexual child abuse, affair(s), yes, there are usually multiple, are incredibly hurtful and there often isn’t much, if anything, the other partner could change to keep the wandering spouse at home. In my first marriage, my wife told me she was sorry the affair hurt me but she wasn’t sorry she’d done it. She claimed that now she knew what it felt like to have sex with someone she truly loved.
    It is possible to forgive and work past even that kind of affair, and we did it, but unfortunately her brokenness led her into other affairs, usually at least one per year.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.